Materials
Reusable vs Biodegradable Seed Trays
An honest comparison of plastic trays, fibre and paper pots, and soil blocks.
Affiliate note: links marked Shop Now go to Amazon. If you buy, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes what we recommend. How we earn money.
Quick answer
Reusable plastic trays are the better value and the more consistent performer if you start seeds every year and look after them. Biodegradable pots make sense for crops that hate root disturbance, like cucumbers and squash. Soil blocks avoid trays entirely but take practice. Neither material is "always better" — it depends on the crop and how you garden.
Side-by-side comparison
| Reusable plastic | Biodegradable pots | Soil blocks | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lifespan | Many seasons if rigid | Single use | Blocker lasts years; blocks are compost |
| Moisture | Stable | Walls wick moisture; dry faster | Exposed sides dry quickly |
| Transplanting | Push plug out | Plant pot and all | Plant whole block |
| Root disturbance | Low if plug is well-rooted | Lowest when the pot breaks down | Low; roots air-prune at edges |
| Upfront cost | Medium–high | Low per pot, recurring | Blocker + mix |
| Cleaning | Needed between uses | None | Clean the blocker only |
Reusable plastic seed trays
Rigid plastic trays hold their shape, drain consistently and make bottom watering easy. Their environmental case depends on lifespan: a heavy-duty tray used for ten seasons is very different from a thin insert thrown away after one. If you choose plastic, buy durable, wash and store it out of sunlight, and it will repay the cost.
- Pros: consistent results, easy to sterilise, long life.
- Cons: higher upfront cost, cheaper versions crack, needs cleaning.
Biodegradable pots and trays
Fibre, coir, paper and wood-pulp pots go into the ground with the plant. That's a real advantage for crops that sulk after root disturbance. The downsides: the walls draw moisture away from the mix, so they dry out quickly, and some materials break down slowly in cool or dry soil. Tear off any rim that would sit above soil level, and slit the sides if roots aren't already growing through.
Peat pots were once the default biodegradable option. Many gardeners now prefer coir, paper or wood-fibre alternatives, and UK gardeners in particular are encouraged to go peat-free.
Soil blocks
A soil blocker compresses moist mix into freestanding cubes. With no walls, roots stop at the edge of the block and branch instead of circling, and there's nothing to wash or throw away. You'll need a mix that holds together, a tray to sit the blocks in, and careful, frequent bottom watering.
Which should you choose?
- Sowing every year, mixed crops → heavy-duty reusable plastic.
- Cucumbers, squash, melons, sweetcorn → biodegradable pots or large cells.
- Avoiding plastic and happy to learn a technique → soil blocks.
- Trying seed starting once → an inexpensive kit, then upgrade.
FAQs
Are plastic seed trays bad for the environment?
Their impact depends on how long they last. Durable trays reused for many seasons are a very different case from thin trays thrown away each year.
Do biodegradable pots break down in the soil?
Most do, but slowly in cold or dry soil. Tear off any rim above ground and slit the sides if roots haven't grown through.
What are soil blocks?
Freestanding cubes of compressed seed mix made with a soil blocker. They need no tray cells and roots air-prune at the edges.
Which crops benefit from biodegradable pots?
Crops that dislike root disturbance, such as cucumbers, squash, melons and sweetcorn.