Grow better, from the very beginning

Best Seed Starter Trays in 2026: Find the Right Tray for Your Garden

Practical guides, honest comparisons and simple tips to help every seed become a healthy seedling — whether you garden in Ohio or Oxfordshire.

  • Cell sizes matched to crops
  • Reusable & biodegradable options
  • No fake "lab tests"
Overhead view of a black 72-cell seed starter tray filled with seedlings on a wooden table

Featured comparison

Best seed starter trays by use

Short version of our full best seed starter trays list. We compare tray types and features — check the listing for current price, size and reviews before you buy.

Affiliate note: links marked Shop Now go to Amazon. If you buy, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes what we recommend. How we earn money.

PickBest forLook forShop
Heavy-duty reusable 72-cell tray kitMost home gardeners who sow every springthick, rigid plastic; a drainage hole in every cell; solid 1020 base tray; vented domeShop Now
All-in-one seed starting kit with domeFirst-time seed startersincluded base tray and dome, height of dome, number of cells, whether labels are includedShop Now
Deep 32- or 50-cell seed trayTomatoes, peppers, auberginescell depth (deeper is better), cell width around 2–2½ in, rigid wallsShop Now
Self-watering seed starter with capillary matBusy growers, holidays, even moisturereservoir size, capillary mat or wick design, ability to drain excessShop Now
Biodegradable fibre or paper seed potsCucumbers, squash, melons, sweetcornmaterial (coir, paper, wood fibre; peat-free if that matters to you), pot size, whether a holding tray is includedShop Now

See all 8 picks and the full comparison

Tray basics

Cell size decides how long seedlings can stay put

Small 128-cell plug trays fit lots of lettuce, herbs and onions into one shelf. A 72-cell insert is the all-rounder most home gardeners reach for. Larger 50- or 32-cell trays give tomatoes, peppers and squash room to build roots before transplanting.

The rule of thumb: the longer a crop will spend indoors and the faster its roots grow, the bigger the cell it needs.

Read the seed tray cell size chart →

Seed tray cell size comparison chart showing 128-cell, 72-cell and 32-cell trays
Same tray footprint, three cell counts: 128, 72 and 32.

Tray types

Four kinds of seed starting trays

Plastic cell trays

Reusable, space-efficient and made in dozens of cell counts. Thicker plastic lasts many seasons; thin flimsy inserts often crack after one or two.

What to check →

Biodegradable pots & trays

Fibre, coir and paper pots can go into the ground with the plant, reducing root disturbance. Some dry out fast, so they need closer watering.

Compare materials →

Soil blocks

A blocker presses freestanding cubes of compost — no cells at all. Roots air-prune at the edges, but you need a suitable mix and careful watering.

How soil blocks compare →

Deep trays & dome kits

Deeper cells and clear humidity domes suit long-season crops and cool rooms, as long as you vent the dome once seeds sprout.

When to remove the dome →
Seedling growth stages in seed tray cells from sown seed to transplant-ready seedling
From sown seed to a transplant ready for hardening off.

Beginner guide

Seed to transplant in ten steps

  1. Moisten seed-starting mix until it feels like a wrung-out sponge.
  2. Fill cells loosely and level — don't pack them down.
  3. Sow at the depth on the packet (roughly 2–3× the seed's width).
  4. Cover with a dome and keep warm until sprouts appear.
  5. Vent the dome, then give strong light right away.

See all ten steps and the printable checklist →

Why trust this site

Research you can check, not hype

We compare seed trays on things that actually change results: cell volume and depth, drainage, plastic thickness, fit with standard 1020 base trays, and how easy they are to clean. Growing advice is checked against university extension guidance, and every guide lists its sources.

We say clearly when a recommendation is research-based rather than hands-on tested, and we never accept payment for placement.

Read our editorial policy →

  • 1Sources from extension services and horticultural bodies
  • 2Same comparison criteria for every tray type
  • 3Clear affiliate disclosure on every buying page
  • 4Guides reviewed and dated each season

Free resource

Printable seed-starting checklist

Everything to gather and do before sowing day, on one page. No email required — open it and print.

Get the checklist

Seed starter tray FAQs

What are the best seed starter trays?

For most gardeners, a rigid, reusable 72-cell insert in a solid base tray with a vented humidity dome. Choose bigger cells for tomatoes and peppers, smaller ones for lettuce and herbs, and biodegradable pots for cucumbers and squash.

What size seed starter tray should I buy?

If you buy one size, make it 72 cells in a standard 1020 (about 10 × 20 inch) tray. It suits most vegetables and flowers. Add 32- or 50-cell trays for crops that stay indoors longer.

Do seed trays need drainage holes?

Yes. Every cell needs a drainage hole so excess water can escape and so you can water from below. The base tray underneath should be solid.

Can you reuse seed starter trays?

Yes, if they are rigid enough to survive cleaning. Scrub, disinfect with a dilute bleach solution, rinse and dry before reusing.

Are biodegradable seed trays better?

Not always. They reduce root disturbance for crops like cucumbers and squash but dry out faster and are single use. Reusable plastic is better value if you start seeds every year.

Ready to choose? Compare current seed starter trays, kits and inserts.

Shop Now on Amazon
↑